Saturday, October 12, 2013

The Accidental Halloween Cookie Surprise

 Quite accidentally we (Pie and I) happened upon a way to make Magic cookies.  
I made Oatmeal-chocolate chip-Sunflower Butter cookies for the Firehouse today. 
When you break them open, or take a bite, you will find they are bright green inside!  
Something in the SUNBUTTER makes the insides green. 

They are delicious. 

The fireman thought the were made with pistachios, but no....
just good for you Sun butter. 

Go to and Follow their Oatmeal Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip cookie recipe, but substitue the Sunbutter for the Peanut butter and PRESTO!
you will have Magic Halloween cookies with green insides! 

  • Boo!


Nancy said...

Hmmm, interesting - I've never seen anything like it before.

Araignee said...


Mereknits said...

How cool is that! I bet they were yummy.

Nancy Kay said...

That's the craziest chocolate chip cookie I've ever seen!!

SissySees said...

Neato!! I wonder if I can sneak sunbutter past the Knight?

KSD said...

That is fantastic!!

Alyssa said...

I wonder what causes that! I will have to try it, though I've never had sun butter. What else can you use it for?

Tanna at The Brick Street Bungalow said...

I've never even seen the Sunbutter! How fun to have green inside! Perfect for Halloween. =) Thank you. blessings ~ tanna

Mrs. Micawber said...

That's amazing - some kind of magic chemistry thing going on there!

I'd never heard of SunButter till now - it sounds interesting. Maybe we'll try making some of our own.

Anonymous said...

Fun cookies. I will have to look for Sunbutter next time I go to Whole Foods.

suburban prep said...

Interesting cookie.
Want a good cookie---Marianos makes a White Chocolate Cherry cookie. One of my down falls. I have a recipes I found on the internet that comes close.

Blog Archive